Blessed be the Emmys rulebook, but it needs some serious updating.
Even though “The Handmaid’s Tale” has taken its final bow, Hulu has confirmed its official Emmy submissions for the critically acclaimed drama, with one entry in particular already causing waves.
Variety has learned exclusively that the streamer has submitted Alexis Bledel in the guest drama actress category for her appearance in the series finale (“610 – The Handmaid’s Tale”), despite a newly enforced Emmy rule disqualifying actors who have been previously nominated in a lead or supporting category for the same show. Bledel, who won the Emmy for guest in 2017, and garnered two additional noms in the same category in 2020 and 2021. However, in 2018, after appearing in seven of the 13 episodes, she was ineligible to compete as a guest; she was submitted and eventually nominated for supporting drama actress. The one-year recognition for her character, Ofglen, appears to fall outside the bounds of eligibility, but the streamer is hopeful the TV Academy will consider her circumstances.
Insiders say Hulu expects the TV Academy to reclassify Bledel’s submission to supporting drama actress before ballots are opened on June 12, but as of now, no decision has been issued.
The rule aims to clarify what defines a “guest” star. According to the new guidelines, any actor previously nominated in a lead or supporting role for a series can no longer be considered a guest, regardless of how briefly they appear in the series.
The policy has already drawn industry-wide criticism and confusion. Meryl Streep, for instance, was ruled ineligible for guest consideration for her turn in Hulu’s “Only Murders in the Building” — despite appearing in just four episodes — and will instead compete in the supporting comedy actress category due to her previous nom. Meanwhile, Paul Rudd, playing a new character in the same series, was nearly eligible as a guest but was in one episode too many, exposing inconsistencies with the changes.
Nonetheless, the guidelines create more ambiguity than clarity. There should be a fundamental difference between a major series lead attempting to go guest and a long-time supporting player who has only occasionally appeared.
Industry voices argue that the change unfairly penalizes performers with limited screen time who have previously been recognized — especially when those appearances are few and far between. Some believe this growing backlash will prompt the Emmys to consider revisions ahead of future cycles.
Despite the rule conflict, “The Handmaid’s Tale” still remains a formidable force in this year’s Emmy race. The drama, which concluded its six-season run on Monday, has garnered 76 nominations and 15 wins over its lifetime — including a historic outstanding drama series win in its first season, the first ever for a streaming platform.
This year, Hulu submitted 36 entries for the show across both Primetime and Creative Arts categories. Notable acting entries include Elisabeth Moss for lead actress and for helming the penultimate episode, “Execution,” which is somewhat surprising considering long-running shows often reserve their final episodes for consideration. However, the episode that sees many favorite characters’ shocking deaths is more visually striking, partnered with June screaming, “Don’t let the bastards grind you down” as she’s being hanged.
In addition, Bradley Whitford, Max Minghella, and O-T Fagbenle will vie in the supporting actor race, while Yvonne Strahovski, Samira Wiley, and Ann Dowd will seek love in supporting actress. Guest actress submissions beyond Bledel include Emmy winners Cherry Jones (episode 602) and D’Arcy Carden (episode 608).
Hulu’s complete 2025 Emmy submission list for “The Handmaid’s Tale” includes:
“I’m trying to do my part — to take the baton, run as far as I can with it, and hand it off to the next.”
- Outstanding Drama Series: Bruce Miller, Eric Tuchman, Yahlin Chang, Warren Littlefield, Elisabeth Moss, and others.
- Outstanding Lead Actress in a Drama Series: Elisabeth Moss
- Outstanding Supporting Actor in a Drama Series: Bradley Whitford, O-T Fagbenle, Max Minghella, Josh Charles, Sam Jaeger, Timothy Simons
- Outstanding Supporting Actress in a Drama Series: Yvonne Strahovski, Ann Dowd, Samira Wiley, Madeline Brewer, Amanda Brugel, Ever Carradine
- Outstanding Guest Actress in a Drama Series: Alexis Bledel (610), Cherry Jones (602), D’Arcy Carden (608)
- Craft and Creative Arts Categories
Outstanding Directing for a Drama Series: Elisabeth Moss (609) - Outstanding Writing for a Drama Series:
- “Exodus” – Yahlin Chang (608)
- “Execution” – Eric Tuchman (609)
- “The Handmaid’s Tale” – Bruce Miller (610)
- Outstanding Cinematography: Nicola Daley (608), Stuart Biddlecombe (610)
- Outstanding Production Design: Elisabeth Williams and team (608)
- Outstanding Contemporary Costumes: Leslie Kavanagh and team (608)
- Outstanding Makeup (Non-Prosthetic): Burton LeBlanc and team (607)
- Outstanding Music Composition: Adam Taylor (609)
- Outstanding Music Supervision: Maggie Phillips, Brittany Whyte (602)
- Outstanding Sound Editing: Full team listed (609)
- Outstanding Sound Mixing: Full team listed (609)
- Outstanding Stunt Coordination: Brian Jagersky
- Outstanding Stunt Performance: Ensemble (609)
- Outstanding Special Visual Effects: Mavericks VFX (610)
- Outstanding Picture Editing: Wendy Hallam Martin (609)
- Outstanding Casting: Sharon Bialy, Russell Scott, Sherry Thomas, Robin D. Cook
- Short Form Submission
Outstanding Short Form Nonfiction or Reality Series: “The Handmaid’s Tale: The End of an Epic”
